Welcome back to Binge Safari, where we comb through the jungles of TV history looking for binge-worthy beasts and mysterious wreckage. Today, we’re digging into Lost, the genre-defining phenomenon that had everyone arguing about smoke monsters, time travel, and whether that ending was genius or garbage.
Created by J.J. Abrams, Damon Lindelof, and Jeffrey Lieber, Lost ran for six seasons from 2004 to 2010 on ABC and is now streaming on Hulu and Disney+. It was a cultural event, a watercooler obsession, and by the end—a full-blown existential breakdown.
Critics Ricky the Reel Raccoon and Fifi the Film Frenchie are here to dig through the wreckage and figure out if this show still deserves a spot in the binge safari canon—or if it should’ve stayed lost.
Ricky’s Review – A Raccoon Crashes, Screams, and Keeps Watching Anyway
Okay listen. Lost is the kind of show that grabs you by the tail in Season 1, drags you through mind-blowing twists, epic character arcs, polar bears, creepy hatches, time loops, and immortal bald guys—and then in Season 6, sets your brain on fire and blames God.
Let’s start with the good: the first three seasons? Chef’s kiss. Pure junk-food chaos. Plane crash survivors wake up on a beach with a bunch of secrets, and suddenly they’re being chased by trees, haunted by dead relatives, and manipulated by a group called The Others, led by Michael Emerson’s deliciously creepy Ben Linus.
The early arcs? Incredible. John Locke (played by Terry O’Quinn) is the island’s culty survivalist MVP. Dude goes from middle-aged office drone to knife-throwing jungle prophet, and I was HOWLING. Hurley (Jorge Garcia) is the soul of the show, a lovable goofball with cursed lotto numbers and surprisingly deep pain.
And can we please talk about the hatch? Season 2’s big mystery with Desmond pushing a button every 108 minutes? That’s what I’m here for—existential dread with a countdown timer.
But then… Season 6. Oh no. Season. Six. It’s like the writers panicked and tried to tie up six seasons of insane mystery with a giant spiritual bow and forgot to bring logic. Time travel? Okay. Parallel universes? Fine. But a sideways purgatory where everyone’s secretly dead and hugging in a church? No thank you.
🗑️ Ricky’s Rating:
S1–3: 🗑️🗑️🗑️🗑️🗑️
S4–5: 🗑️🗑️🗑️
S6: 🔥🗑️ (Dumpster fire I wouldn’t even cook on.)
Fifi’s Review – The Snarky Cinephile Breaks Down the Mystery
Darlings, I was obsessed with Lost… until Lost decided it was obsessed with itself. This show began as a thrilling, character-driven drama with just the right sprinkle of sci-fi and mystery. By Season 6? It was like a philosophy major took over and forgot to return the plot.
But we must honor what it did well. Evangeline Lilly’s Kate, Matthew Fox’s Jack, and Josh Holloway’s Sawyer formed the show’s complicated central triangle—and honestly, I lived for their tension. Sawyer’s sarcasm? Peak bad-boy energy. Jack’s tortured brooding? Predictable but watchable. And Kate? Give that woman a backpack and some emotional confusion and she’ll carry a season.
And oh, the music! Composer Michael Giacchino delivered one of the most iconic TV scores of all time—his emotional piano work still makes me weep when I hear the theme.
Behind the scenes, the writing team included future heavy-hitters like Carlton Cuse and Drew Goddard, and they really swung for the fences in terms of world-building. I’ll give them credit: few shows have ever been this ambitious—or this willing to fly into absurdity at full speed.
Still, the show’s final message—that everyone needed to find each other in death to “move on”? I’ve had deeper emotional closure from an expired yogurt.
🐾 Fifi’s Rating:
S1–3: 🐾🐾🐾🐾🐾
S4–5: 🐾🐾🐾
S6: 🐾 (And that’s only because of Giacchino’s piano.)
Final Thoughts – A Binge Worth Getting Lost In (Until It Isn’t)
Ricky and Fifi agree: Lost is a legendary show that flew high, then crash-landed in a fog of its own metaphysics. But despite the bonkers ending, it changed television, inspired a generation of mystery box dramas, and made millions of fans scream at their TVs.
📢 Stream Lost now on Hulu or Disney+, and join us next time on Binge Safari, where we chase the thrill, dodge the plot holes, and always find something worth digging into.
Leave a Reply